Great American Cookies expanded beyond cookie cakes into hand-packed ice cream, shakes, and sundaes, while keeping its signature occasion-themed cookie cake designs for birthdays and holidays. Note: prices below reflect a Grubhub delivery listing rather than in-store pricing.
Below you'll find 30 Great American Cookies menu items across 7 categories, with prices ranging from $2.49 to $36.2. Actual prices can differ by city, state, and whether you order in-store, through the app, or via a delivery service — use this as a planning guide rather than a final quote.
Order, Tip & Split Calculator
Tap + / - to add items, pick a tip, and split the bill if you're ordering as a group. Estimate only — taxes, fees, and delivery charges are not included.
Subtotal$0.00
Add a tip
Split between
1
people
Grand total$0.00
Per person$0.00
Ice Cream
Hand-Packed Quarts
$19.99
Hand-Packed Pints
$14.99
Ice Cream CupsBEST VALUE
$8.85+
Classic Favorites
Strawberry Caramel CheesecakeBEST VALUE
$11.20+
Cookies 'N Cream
$19.99+
Cotton Candy Carnival
$19.99+
Chocolate Caramel Butter PecanBEST VALUE
$11.20+
Cookie Dough SurpriseBEST VALUE
$11.20+
Rocky Road
$19.99+
Candy Bar Blast
$19.99+
S'mores
$19.99+
Coffee Crunch
$19.99+
Birthday Bash
$19.99+
Cookies & Brownies
Cookie Cake by the SliceBEST VALUE
$6.49+
Double Doozies
$7.50+
Regular Cookies
$36.20+
Shakes
Cookie ShakeBEST VALUE
$10.03+
Create Your Own ShakeBEST VALUE
$10.03+
Cookies & Cream ShakeBEST VALUE
$10.03+
Snickers ShakeBEST VALUE
$10.03+
Coffee ShakeBEST VALUE
$10.03+
Cotton Candy ShakeBEST VALUE
$10.03+
Strawberry ShakeBEST VALUE
$10.03+
Sundaes
Cookie Sundae
$11.20
Strawberry Shortcake Sundae
$11.20
Banana Split Sundae
$11.79
Fudge Brownie Sundae
$11.20
Classic SundaeBEST VALUE
$10.91
Beverages
Bottled BeveragesBEST VALUE
$2.49+
Party Supplies
Number CandlesBEST VALUE
$4.69
Catering
Great American Cookies offers catering for groups and events at many US locations. Package availability and pricing vary by store, so treat the prices below as a starting estimate and confirm with your local location before ordering.
Birthday Cookie Cake
$53.74+
4th Of July Flag Cookie Cake
$53.74+
Holiday Spirit Cookie Cake
$53.74+
Blue Snowman Cookie Cake
$53.74+
You Won My Heart Cookie Cake
$53.74+
I Love You Cookie Cake
$53.74+
Best Mom Ever Cookie Cake
$44.99+
Coolest Pop Cookie Cake
$53.74+
#1 Dad Coffee Mug Cookie Cake
$53.74+
This is an independent, unofficial guide to Great American Cookies’ menu. Prices vary by location and change over time — not affiliated with or endorsed by Great American Cookies. See how we source this data. Hours also vary by location — find your nearest store's hours.
Tips for Ordering at Great American Cookies
Combo or meal deals usually work out cheaper per item than ordering the same pieces separately.
The official app often carries app-only deals that aren't shown on the in-store board.
Prices at airport, mall, and highway rest-stop locations typically run higher than standard locations.
Call ahead or check the location's own listing if you need an exact, current price for your specific store.
Frequently Asked Questions about Great American Cookies Prices
Does Great American Cookies deliver?
Many locations offer delivery through Grubhub and other third-party platforms alongside their own carryout options.
What occasion-themed cookie cakes are available?
Birthday, summer/patriotic, winter holiday, Valentine's Day, Mother's Day, and Father's Day designs are all available as custom-decorated cookie cakes.