Five Guys vs Shake Shack
Live comparison — updates automatically as prices changeBoth chains built their reputation on a smaller, higher-quality burger menu than typical fast food, and both price well above a drive-thru chain as a result. Five Guys includes unlimited free toppings and hand-cut fries; Shake Shack leans on its ShackSauce and frozen custard shakes as the signature draw.
Five Guysruns cheaper on average, by about $0.27 per item
Menu Item Comparison
| Five Guys: Little Hamburger | $8.61+ |
| Shake Shack: ShackBurger (Single) | $7.79 |
| Five Guys: Little Cheeseburger | $9.76+ |
| Shake Shack: ShackBurger (Double) | $10.79 |
| Five Guys: Little Bacon Burger | $9.76+ |
| Shake Shack: Hamburger (Single) | $6.49 |
| Five Guys: Little Bacon Cheeseburger | $10.91+ |
| Shake Shack: Cheeseburger (Single) | $7.29 |
| Five Guys: Hamburger | $10.57+ |
| Shake Shack: 'Shroom Burger | $8.49 |
| Five Guys: Cheeseburger | $11.72+ |
| Shake Shack: Chick'n Shack | $8.29 |
| Five Guys: Bacon Burger | $11.72+ |
| Shake Shack: Crinkle Cut Fries | $3.49 |
| Five Guys: Bacon Cheeseburger | $12.64+ |
The Verdict
Five Guys tends to run a bit higher per burger once you factor in the larger portion sizes, while Shake Shack's single burger is closer to a standard fast-food price point. Neither is a budget pick — pick based on whether you want fries by the bag or a proper milkshake.
This comparison pulls live price data from each restaurant's page on this site. Prices are estimates and vary by location for both restaurants — see our price sourcing methodology for details.